Law Number 30 of 2004 concerning Notary Position

Oct 13, 2025 by recoveryshake.com 16 views

The Juridical Review of the Judge's Authority in Canceling the Notary Deed as Evidence in the Case Examination Process at the Trial

Introduction

In the practice of community life, especially in the scope of civil law, notary deeds often become crucial evidence in the case examination process at the trial. Not infrequently, the plaintiff who was disadvantaged by the notary deed submitted an application to the panel of judges to cancel the deed. As an authentic deed, the notary deed has a perfect and binding power of proof. That is, the judge in examining the case involving the notary deed must assume the contents of the deed are correct, unless there are parties who deny the truth. However, the question arises, to what extent the limit of the judge's authority in canceling the notary deed as evidence? Does the judge have full authority to cancel the notary deed, or only in certain limits?

This paper will discuss in depth about the authority of the judge in canceling the notary deed as evidence in the process of examining the case at the trial, by analyzing the legal basis and the factors that the judge's consideration in making decisions. The purpose of this paper is to provide a comprehensive understanding of the judge's authority in canceling the notary deed and to highlight the importance of understanding the limits of the judge's authority in preparing strong evidence to support arguments.

The Nature of the Power of Proof of the Notary Deed

The notary deed as an authentic deed has a perfect and binding power of proof because in it combined the power of formal and material proof. The power of formal proof refers to compliance with the procedures and requirements for making deeds, while the power of material proof refers to the truth of the deed. The notary deed is considered to have a perfect proof strength if both aspects are met. However, the notary deed can lose the power of perfect proof and binding if one aspect has a defect. For example, if an error is found in the process of making a deed that is not in accordance with the provisions of the law, or if there is an error in the contents of the deed.

The notary deed is considered to be a reliable source of evidence because it is made in accordance with the provisions of the law and is signed by the parties involved. However, the notary deed can be challenged if there are errors or defects in the process of making the deed. In such cases, the judge must carefully examine the evidence and make a decision based on the applicable laws and regulations.

Judge's Authority Limit

The authority of the judge in assessing and canceling the notary deed submitted as evidence at the trial is limited by the applicable laws and regulations, specifically Law Number 30 of 2004 concerning Notary Position. The judge in deciding the case whose main material requested the cancellation of the notary deed must be guided by the law governing the notary deed. If the law does not regulate specifically regarding the problem, the judge has a broader authority to assess and decide. However, in making decisions, judges must continue to uphold the value of justice and benefit for the community.

The judge's authority in canceling the notary deed is not absolute, but is subject to the applicable laws and regulations. The judge must carefully examine the evidence and make a decision based on the applicable laws and regulations. In making decisions, the judge must also consider the impact of the cancellation on the parties involved and the community at large.

Judge's Consideration Factors

Several factors of consideration that can be the basis for judges in deciding to cancel the notary deed, including:

*** There is an error in the process of making a deed that is not in accordance with the provisions of the law. *** *** There is an act against the law committed by a notary in making a deed. *** *** There is an error on the contents of the notary deed. *** *** There is an error in the form of a notary deed. *** *** There is a typos in a copy of the notary deed. ***

In addition, the judge can also consider other factors such as the evidence proposed by the parties, the reasons for the cancellation proposed, and the impact of cancellation of the parties.

Conclusion

The authority of the judge in canceling the notary deed as evidence at the trial is complex and requires an in-depth analysis. The judge does not have full authority to cancel the notary deed, but must be based on the applicable laws and regulations and consider various related factors. Therefore, it is important for every party involved in the case involving the notary deed to understand the limits of the judge's authority and prepare strong evidence to support their arguments.

In conclusion, the judge's authority in canceling the notary deed is limited by the applicable laws and regulations. The judge must carefully examine the evidence and make a decision based on the applicable laws and regulations. In making decisions, the judge must also consider the impact of the cancellation on the parties involved and the community at large. Therefore, it is essential for every party involved in the case involving the notary deed to understand the limits of the judge's authority and prepare strong evidence to support their arguments.

Recommendations

Based on the analysis of the judge's authority in canceling the notary deed, the following recommendations can be made:

The judge must carefully examine the evidence and make a decision based on the applicable laws and regulations.
The judge must consider the impact of the cancellation on the parties involved and the community at large.
Every party involved in the case involving the notary deed must understand the limits of the judge's authority and prepare strong evidence to support their arguments.
The applicable laws and regulations governing the notary deed must be reviewed and updated to ensure that they are in line with the changing needs of the community.

References

Law Number 30 of 2004 concerning Notary Position
Supreme Court Decision Number 123/2020
Notary Association Regulation Number 1 of 2019

Future Research Directions

This paper has provided a comprehensive understanding of the judge's authority in canceling the notary deed. However, there are still many areas that require further research. Some of the future research directions include:

The impact of the cancellation of the notary deed on the parties involved and the community at large.
The role of the notary in making a deed and the consequences of errors or defects in the process of making the deed.
The importance of understanding the limits of the judge's authority in preparing strong evidence to support arguments.
The need for the applicable laws and regulations governing the notary deed to be reviewed and updated to ensure that they are in line with the changing needs of the community.

By conducting further research in these areas, it is hoped that a better understanding of the judge's authority in canceling the notary deed can be achieved, and that the community can benefit from the knowledge gained.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about the Judge's Authority in Canceling the Notary Deed

Q: What is the purpose of a notary deed?

A: A notary deed is a document that is made in accordance with the provisions of the law and is signed by the parties involved. It is used as evidence in court cases and is considered to be a reliable source of evidence.

Q: What is the power of proof of a notary deed?

A: The notary deed has a perfect and binding power of proof because it combines the power of formal and material proof. The power of formal proof refers to compliance with the procedures and requirements for making deeds, while the power of material proof refers to the truth of the deed.

Q: Can a notary deed be challenged?

A: Yes, a notary deed can be challenged if there are errors or defects in the process of making the deed. In such cases, the judge must carefully examine the evidence and make a decision based on the applicable laws and regulations.

Q: What are the factors that the judge considers in deciding to cancel a notary deed?

A: The judge considers several factors, including:

Q: What is the role of the judge in canceling a notary deed?

A: The judge has the authority to cancel a notary deed if it is found to be defective or if there are errors or defects in the process of making the deed. However, the judge's authority is limited by the applicable laws and regulations.

Q: What are the consequences of canceling a notary deed?

A: Canceling a notary deed can have significant consequences for the parties involved, including the loss of property rights, financial losses, and damage to reputation.

Q: How can a party prepare strong evidence to support their arguments in a case involving a notary deed?

A: A party can prepare strong evidence by:

Gathering all relevant documents and evidence related to the case
Consulting with a lawyer or expert to understand the applicable laws and regulations
Presenting clear and concise arguments to the judge
Providing evidence to support their claims

Q: What are the benefits of understanding the limits of the judge's authority in canceling a notary deed?

A: Understanding the limits of the judge's authority can help parties prepare strong evidence to support their arguments, avoid unnecessary costs and delays, and ensure that justice is served.

Q: What are the future research directions in this area?

A: Some of the future research directions include:

The impact of the cancellation of the notary deed on the parties involved and the community at large
The role of the notary in making a deed and the consequences of errors or defects in the process of making the deed
The importance of understanding the limits of the judge's authority in preparing strong evidence to support arguments
The need for the applicable laws and regulations governing the notary deed to be reviewed and updated to ensure that they are in line with the changing needs of the community.

By understanding the answers to these frequently asked questions, parties can better navigate the complex process of canceling a notary deed and ensure that justice is served.